Logos in Aretha Franklin's "Respect"

Franklin’s version of Respect includes aspects that are different from Otis Redding’s version of the song. The changes that she has made to the song create a whole new dimension that stresses the power behind the choices that a woman has. Hidden within the lyrics of the song Respect there is a clear message that Franklin is able to send her audience. Often one does not think of lyrics as the source for logical arguments, but the order that Franklin follows is nothing but logical. The song begins with a request for respect; however, as the song progresses she explains why she is someone who deserves this respect. She starts with explaining her faithfulness, “I ain't gonna do you wrong, while you're gone…. Cause I don't want to (ooh).” Here one can understand that even though she believes in making her own choices she has not gone against the expectation of loyalty in a relationship. In Redding’s version he explains that he doesn’t mind if the woman goes around behind his back. By putting these two lyrics alongside each other it is easy to see why Franklin’s version shows the power within a woman’s choices. Another why she justifies the respect she needs is by saying “I’m about to give you all my money.” This same lyric is used in the older version of the song. However, in Franklin’s version of the song it serves a new purpose. It shows that Franklin treats her man well. Thus, it is only logical if her lover does the same for her. One of the most significant and arguably the most powerful changes in the song pertais to the last few lines. She sings, “Or you might walk in and find out I’m gone.” Here she wants her lover to realize that she’s not the type of woman to stay with someone who doesn’t treat her right- she is not afraid to walk away. This gives the need for respect a sense of urgency because she can leave if she does not receive it. Franklin skillfully crafts her argument for respect by emphasizing how she is deserving of it rather than blatantly saying she needs it.